Top Rated 10 Best Crib Mattress Reviews 2017

Searching for the top rated crib mattress for your child can be a painstaking process. Have you been having trouble finding the best mattress for them? Do you know even where to begin?

With many different factors playing into your choice, including maintaining your child’s comfort while eliminating the risk for sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), it’s valuably important to learn everything there is needed to know before making your crib mattress purchase.

Lucky for you, here in this article, we are going to guide you through everything that you need to know in order to find and purchase the very best crib mattress for your child.

Here, we will walk you through the various differences between different crib mattresses and their characteristics, including levels of mattress support, comfort, density, breathability, ease of cleaning, foam and spring mattresses, innerspring mattresses, weight, waterproof technology, chemicals used in their making, and organic content.

Additionally, we are going to take a look at the top 10 rated crib mattresses for children so you will be able to see real products that are available to you and your family right now!

Even more, we will be showing you the most important considerations to keep in mind when shopping for and looking at investing in a new mattress for cribs. 

Without further ado, let’s get started!

Let’s begin by looking at the multiple crib mattress parameters to keep in mind when searching for a new crib mattress. You will want to keep in mind the support, comfort, density, breathability, ease of cleaning, foam and spring mattresses, innerspring mattresses, weight, waterproof technology, chemicals used in their making, and organic content of each mattress to ensure the mattress is the best for you and your child and what you are looking for.

1. COMFORT

Even though you will be looking for a crib mattress that is more firm, that doesn’t mean the mattress won’t be comfortable!

You can definitely find a firm crib mattress that is very comfortable for your child or your infant.

Each mattress offers a differing level of comfort depending upon the materials it is made out of along with its differences in construction. 

You will still be able to find the ideal comfort level for you by looking at each of the following crib mattresses (to be described later in the article) and learning all about them.

This will give you the best information for making the best informed decision that you can!

2. DENSITY

The density of the crib mattress you are looking for will relate to the comfort level and the firmness level of your mattress.

Again, be sure to keep in mind that you would like a mattress that is more firm so that your child can be as protected as possible throughout the night and so you can rest assured as well knowing that your child is sleeping soundly and safely.

Mattresses made out of different materials will have different levels of density. 

For example, foam and spring mattresses will have different density levels and innerspring mattresses will have different density levels as well.

Even more, you can select different density levels no matter the type of mattress you are looking for.

By keeping the density factor in mind, you can make the best crib mattress purchase for your child.

3. BREATHABILITY

It is very important to find and invest in a crib mattress that has superb breathability.

This includes strong venting capabilities that will allow for various smells and odors to pass their way through.

A breathable mattress will help to keep itself clean, even when some unruly odors and fluids land on the mattress.

For infants and small children, breathability is one of the most important characteristics to keep in mind when selecting a mattress, in addition to firmness level.

Since you can expect leakage on the mattress, a mattress that has high breathability will be able to withstand the test of time and will be able to last longer than other mattresses that are not as breathable, saving your pocketbook in the long run.

4. EASE OF CLEANING

Bouncing off the need for a breathable crib mattress, you will want to be sure to look for a crib mattress that is very easy to clean.

Being made out of a material that is cleanable and wipeable to clean up those messes that are sure to be found on your child or infant’s crib mattress.

Most crib mattresses are suggested to be cleaned via spot-clean only; however, some crib mattresses offer washable covers that lend to the ease of cleanliness for the mattress.

Additionally, you can also invest in more washable covers that can protect your crib mattress from messes, spills, and leaks.

5. FOAM OR SPRING MATTRESS

Is there a certain material you are looking for or that your child has expressed interest in? Have you been thinking more of a foam mattress or a spring mattress in respect to an innerspring?

Foam mattresses tend to be the lightest options available. Foam mattresses also vary in thicknesses, ranging anywhere between three to six inches in thickness.

Here is where you will want to pay close attention to how firm and dense the mattress is as you will want to specifically look for foam mattresses that are more firm, heavy, and resilient, no matter how thick it measures out to be.

In finding the most firm foam or spring mattress you can, while still being comfortable to your child and infant, you can protect your child from sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS).

6. INNERSPRING

Innerspring mattresses are also available for the best crib mattress that you are looking for.

This style of mattress is characterized by steel coils covered with foam, padding, and fabrics.

If you are looking for the best innerspring crib mattress for your child’s crib size, you will want to look for innerspring mattresses that have better-gauge steel and are made of a higher-quality cushioning material that is still heavy.

This might be on the more expensive side of the totality of the mattresses that are available to you.

However, this type of mattress will likely be more firm and durable as well.

7. WEIGHT

The weight of the mattress is an important characteristic to consider for your child’s crib mattress.

The crib mattress weight relates back to the density, firmness, and resilience of the mattress itself and the comfort level it is able to provide.

While comfort is a key factor, your child’s and infant’s overall health is more important.

So sometimes a heavier mattress is able to provide a greater firmness and density level that will help to keep your child very safe throughout the entirety of their sleep.

Foam mattresses tend to be lighter in weight than innerspring mattresses, yet they can still be just as durable, firm, and comfortable.

8. WATERPROOF

Is the crib mattress you are looking for waterproof and does it have waterproof protection capabilities?

You will likely want to invest in a waterproof crib mattress, especially given the high possibility for diaper leakage and fluids coming in contact with the mattress surface itself.

Being waterproof will help the mattress to be more resilient to wear and tear and will help to tremendously ease the clean-up process for you, making this a strong personal benefit for you!

Waterproof mattresses are often more easy to clean than crib mattresses that are not waterproof, so look for these types of crib mattresses during your crib mattress search.

9. CHEMICAL FREE CRIB MATTRESS

However, with new regulations, modern and new crib mattresses are often free of such chemicals, but you will still want to be sure that the crib mattress you are interested in is void of any dangerous materials.

New crib mattress that are for sale in the United States are required to meet certain and particular safety standard that have been defined by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission and the American Society for Testing and Materials.

You will want to be sure to look for an Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certification which confirms to you that the mattress was not made by certain heavy metals and flame retardants, keeping you, your child, and your entire family safe.

10. ORGANIC CRIB MATTRESS

Lastly, you will want to take a look at the organic content that is used to make the mattress you are interested in, especially if staying organic is an important factor for you.

There are many organic crib mattresses which are constructed of all-natural or all-organic materials which would include cotton, wool, coconut fibers, food-grade polymers, plant-based foam, and natural latex.

These types of mattresses can be found as either foam or innerspring-type mattresses. Some might even be stuffed with fibers of coconut husks.

While these mattresses are often more expensive than non-organic mattresses, they are known to be worth the extra dollars spent because of the increased safety that is presented to you and your child.

For example, organic mattresses are free of substances that could potentially harm babies, which many of these substances are traditionally found or used in the construction of non-organic crib mattresses.

10 Best Top Rated Crib Mattresses

Now that we have a greater understanding on what to look for when purchasing a new crib mattress, let’s investigate the top 10 crib mattresses that are available to you and your family on the market today.

These mattresses were selected because of the overall ratings they received from critics and consumers as well as the features and specifications that make each mattress for crib unique.

Sl. No.

Product Details

Type

Dimensions

Weight

Warranty

Our Rating

Price

Newton Crib Mattress & Toddler Mattress 100% Breathable Washable Recyclable made with Wovenaire

100% Organic

28 x 5.5 x 52 Inches

11 Pounds

Lifetime Limited Warranty

4.8 / 5 

$$$

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic 150 Seamless Dual Firmness Crib Mattress

100% Organic

27.8 x 6 x 52 Inches

20 Pounds

Lifetime Warranty

4.6 / 5

$$$

Best Crib Mattress Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness Crib Mattress (FFP)

Foam

27.5 x 5 x 52 Inches

10.3 Pounds 

Lifetime Limited Warranty

4.7 / 5

$$$

Best Crib Mattress Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Ultra Deluxe 2 n 1 Crib and Toddler Mattress

Inner spring

27.5 x 6 x 52 Inches

25.4 Pounds

Lifetime Limited Warranty

4.5 / 5

$$

Best Crib Mattress Sealy Soybean Serenity Foam-Core Infant Toddler Crib Mattress

Foam Soy Bean

27.2 x 5 x 51.6 Inches

9.2 Pounds

Lifetime Limited Warranty

4.7 / 5

$$$

Best Crib Mattress My First Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress with Plush Removable Waterproof Cover

Memory Foam

51.6 x 5 x 27.2 Inches

11.9 Pounds

10 Year Limited

4.6 / 5

$$

Best Crib Mattress Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

Non-Organic

52.5 x 5.5 X 27.5 Inches

7.7 Pounds

2 Year Warranty

4.5 / 5

$$

Foam

52 x 5.5 X 27.5 Inches

10.8 Pounds

30 Day Return

4.7 / 5

$$

Best Crib Mattress Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress, Twilight

Coil

51 x 5 X 27 Inches

12 Pounds

10 Year Limited

4.4 / 5

$$

Best Crib Mattress American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib and Toddler Protective Mattress Pad Cover, White

Pad Cover

52 x 9 x 28 Inches

11.2 Ounces

NA

4.7 / 5

$$

Newton Crib Mattress & Toddler Mattress

The Newton Crib Mattress & Toddler Mattress: 100% Breathable, Washable, Recyclable made with Wovenaire is a leading mattress is the crib mattress industry. This mattress is known as being “better than organic” and is hypoallergenic and non-toxic.

This mattress is made without foam, latex, springs, or glue, helping to keep your infant and child safe throughout the entire duration of their time with the mattress.

The Newton Crib Mattress & Toddler Mattress has been recommended by Dr. Jim Sears and many additional pediatricians for the health, safety, and proper development of your baby and your child.

This mattress features a design that is 100% breathable, allowing babies and children to breathe directly through the mattress, a feature that significantly reduces the risk of suffocation.

Additionally, this allows for prime air circulation which prevents from sweaty backs and overheating.

This well-recommended mattress is completely washable up to the highest level of hygiene and is 100% recyclable, thanks to being made free from foam, latex, springs, glues, and allergens.

Even though it can be a little on the pricy side, this mattress has been providing parents with peace of mind as their children go to sleep.

Of all the mattresses on this list, this is the only mattress that has been recognized as officially being breathable.

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic 150 Seamless Dual Firmness Crib Mattress

The Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic 150 Seamless Dual Firmness Crib Mattress is a mattress that is made out of cotton that is 100% organic.

This mattress is made in the United States and it features a two-stage dual firmness level to allow this mattress to benefit you and your child for many years.

The two-stage dual firmness level means that one side of the mattress is more firm, ideal for infants, while the other side of the mattress is a little softer, ideal for toddlers and young children.

This feature helps this mattress to be useful to you and your family for many, many years. It’s also the best dual sided crib mattress.

When your child begins to grow out of the infant stage and SIDS (sudden infant death syndrome) is no longer a concern, you can flip the mattress over from the more firm infant side to the softer toddler side.

This mattress comes standard with a wipe-clean waterproof surface that is in fact so pure that it meets food contact standard regulations.

Waterproof seams throughout the entirety of the mattress help to prevent moisture from penetrating the surface of the mattress which helps to allow for even easier cleaning for you.

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness Crib Mattress (FFP)

The Moonlight Slumber - Little Dreamer is a dual firmness crib mattress perfect for the little ones in your family. This mattress is free of vinyl, poluethylene, and PVC in its construction and is also phthalate and lead free, non-toxic waterproof, and features durable nylon cove.

This mattress is a 2 stage crib mattress that has a more firm side for infants and a more soft side for toddlers and young children once they have progressed beyond the infant stage.

The infant side features an extra firm high-density foam set while the toddler side features a firm high-density foam too.

All of the foam utilized in the making of this mattress is registered with a CertiPUR certification, showcasing the prime materials used.

The Moonlight Slumber - Little Dreamer mattress has side stitched seams to help keep the mattress waterproof, keeping leaks and spills from penetrating through the mattress itself.

Plus, this is a hypoallergenic mattress, is treated to showcase ultra-freshness for antimicrobial protection, and is easily cleaned with a damp sponge.

This solid mattress is a reliable crib mattress option for infants to young children.

With many of the great features included with this mattress, you will be able to sleep soundly knowing your child is sleeping soundly as well.

Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Ultra Deluxe 2 n 1 Crib and Toddler Mattress, Neutral

The Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Ultra Deluxe 2 n 1 Crib and Toddler Mattress, Neutral is stuffed with 231 luxury pocketed coil springs that work evenly to provide even support throughout the entire mattress.

A reinforced border and edge adds to the protection of the mattress while innofoam corner protectors provide additional stability for the mattress.

Two features that will come in very handy to you as a parent.

This mattress has a natural cotton fire protection wrap that is non-toxic and is made from no chemicals, additionally meeting or exceeding all flammability standards set forth by the federal level.

Even more, the super woven fabric cover characteristic of this mattress includes a medical-grade waterproof barrier, keeping this mattress safe and clean to withstand the test of time.

This woven cover is resistant to both water and stains.

Lastly, the Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Ultra Deluxe 2 n 1 Crib and Toddler Mattress, Neutral features a 2 in 1 design.

One side of the mattress provides the ideal firmness for infants and the other side of the mattress provides the ideal firmness level for toddlers, ensuring that this mattress will be able to benefit you and your child for many years to come.

Sealy Soybean Serenity Organic Crib Mattress

The Sealy Soybean Serenity Organic Crib Mattress is a two-stage mattress for both infants and toddlers.

This mattress is made from a hypoallergenic soy foam that is extra firm, keeping your infant and young child safe throughout their entire time with this mattress.

This mattress has an organic cotton woven fabric cover that is enhanced with GREENGUARD Certified Crypton Clean Sleep Technology.

This is an eco-friendly barrier that is waterproof and hypoallergenic to keep the whole mattress clean and fresh, both on the inside of the mattress and on the outside as well.

No plastics, such as PVC, vinyl, and polyethylene, are used in the making of or the construction of this mattress and the fabric itself is Oeko-Tex Certified safe for children.

This soy foam crib mattress is unique because of the high-density soybean foam core that is used to give life to this mattress.

The soybean foam material has been recognized to be lightweight and durable, achieving CertiPUR US Certification for its high-quality and for being a more safe alternative to non-certified foams.

Of all the mattresses included on this list, this is the only one that is made out of soy foam. This unique property might be a strong benefit to you if this factor is important to you and your family.

My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam Infant Crib Mattress with Removable Waterproof Cover

The My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam Infant Crib Mattress with Removable Waterproof Cover is an ideal baby mattress for the young infant in your family.

This mattress is designed to fit all standard size cribs and is constructed of flexible polyurethane foam that is CertiPUR US Certified. A removable crib mattress that is soft, waterproof, and washable is featured as standard with this mattress as well.

This baby mattress is designed to not only meet all standard crib sizes, but also meets and exceeds all federal requirements for flammability standards and CPSC standards as well.

The My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam Infant Crib Mattress with Removable Waterproof Cover is hypoallergenic and mite-proof, anti-microbial, and both phthalate free and lead free, too.

While many of the mattresses we have looked at so far on this list are 2 sided mattresses with a side designated for infants and a side designated for toddlers, it is important to recognize that this mattress is strictly for infants.

The memory foam construction of the mattress has a concern for increasing the risk of SIDS, so additional information should be sought before purchasing this mattress. The risk of SIDS should always be taken very seriously, so additional insight is a must.

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress is an imported hypoallergenic crib mattress that provides firm support to your child thanks to the high-density thermo-bonded fiber core that makes this mattress the great mattress that it is.

It is able to sustain the child’s slumber throughout your child’s development thanks to the durable and lightweight design of the mattress, making it ideal for long-lasting use.

This mattress has a vinyl cover that is waterproof and wipes clean nice and easily, making clean-up of any spill or leak a breeze.

Additionally, this mattress is free of lead and phthalates and has been recognized as reaching GREENGUARD Gold Certification, showcasing its prime quality.

This mattress is able to fit all standard crib size bed and toddler beds as well.

While this mattress is recognized to be a good fit for both infants and toddlers, it does not feature the two-stage design that many of the mattresses on this list feature.

This means that while your child will be able to use this mattress from infancy to young childhood, there is no difference in the firmness level they will experience as they grow.

This can grow to be uncomfortable for the child as they age and as the mattress becomes more used over time.

Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress or Toddler Bed Mattress With Waterproof Encasement - 27.5”x52”x5.5"

The Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress or Toddler Bed Mattress With Waterproof Encasement - 27.5”x52”x5.5" is a unique mattress that has a blend of foams which combine together to create the perfect and most ideal combination of comfort and safety for infants all the way up to toddlers.

Your child will not have to worry about the sometimes-uncomfortable spring mattress or non-quality synthetic blends of materials thanks to the great materials that make this mattress everything that it is.

A reinforced mattress encasement is standard with this mattress as well. This encasement is waterproof on both the top and on the sides of itself while still allowing for air and heat to ventilate through the bottom of the mattress.

This encasement is made without any chemicals and is made from anti-flame materials, keeping your child safe throughout time.

While this mattress is comfortable, there could potentially be some concern with how firm it is. Additional research should be completed before purchasing this mattress for your infant; however, your toddler will enjoy it.

Again, reducing the risks for SIDS (sudden infant death syndrome) should always be taken seriously and should never be taken lightly.

Therefore, the additional information you should consider with this mattress should offer more insight on the matter of SIDS with this mattress.

Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress, Twilight

The Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress, Twilight is a lightweight innerspring mattress that includes 80 interwoven coils that are heat tempered.

All of these coils combine together with one another to offer and provide an ideal firm foundation for excellent support for your baby and toddler.

This mattress has a six-gauge steel border wire around its perimeter that focuses on adhering to the support and stability of the mattress itself.

There are two hypoallergenic layers on the mattress which offer additional comfort and cushion while still being firm and steady for a safe night sleep.

The Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress, Twilight has an airflow pocket standard in it that works to help keep the crib mattress itself fresh and clean without the additional needed use of metal vents.

This airflow pocket is a feature that is unique to this mattress in relation to the other mattresses on this list.

The pocket can become a very handy feature to you as a parent as it can help you to protect your child from unwanted bacteria’s.

And can even protect your pocketbook as it can keep the mattress in mint condition for longer time so you don’t have to purchase a new one anytime soon.

Plus, even more, an antibacterial and waterproof lock stitching works to help prevent mold, mildew, and odor from ever becoming an issue.

American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib and Toddler Protective Mattress Pad Cover, White

The last mattress we are going to take a look at is the American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib and Toddler Protective Mattress Pad Cover, White.

This mattress pad, from top to bottom, is made of 100% soft polyester along with waterproof vinyl in the middle to protect from leaks, spills, and accidents.

These waterproof pads not only help to keep the mattress and your child safe, but they help to add soft quilted cushion for additional comfort and relaxation for your child.

Because of the materials it is made out of, this mattress pad allows for easy clean up. Simply peel it off the mattress and toss it in the wash.

This great ability for easy clean allows for the mattress pad to withstand the test of time, lasting for many years to come.

This mattress pad would be the ideal accessory for the firm mattress. If your child has a firm mattress and is looking for a little extra comfort, this would be a wonderful option for them.

However, it might not be the best idea for an already soft mattress, especially for younger children, as the risk for SIDS could potentially increase. Additional information about this mattress pad in relation to SIDS should be considered and sought after.

Conclusion

Phew, who knew there could be so much to know about crib mattresses!

Finding, selecting, and choosing the most proper mattress for your child can be a difficult process. There are many multiple things to consider when looking at the ideal mattress.

Things to consider include levels of mattress support, comfort, density, breathability, ease of cleaning, foam and spring mattresses, innerspring mattresses, weight, waterproof technology, chemicals used in their making, and organic content.

Safety is also a tremendous concern, especially for infants and babies, as you will want to be sure to invest in a mattress that protects against SIDS (sudden infant death syndrome).

By looking at the various characteristics of each of the top 10 top rated crib mattresses available to you and your family on the market today, the Newton Crib Mattress & Toddler Mattress: 100% Breathable, Washable, Recyclable made with Wovenaire shows itself to be a leader in its class and a phenomenal choice for a crib mattress.

Additionally, the Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Ultra Deluxe 2 n 1 Crib and Toddler Mattress, Neutral is a wonderful mattress to choose as well.

Both of these mattresses provide the necessary safety precautions to keep you infant to young child safe while still having comfortable features and recommendations to allow for many years of use, saving your pocketbook in the long run.

We hope this guide has been able to assist you in your crib mattress search. Now that you know what to keep in mind and consider throughout the crib mattress buying process, you can rest assured knowing you will be able to make a sound decision when it comes to the mattress you purchase!

Your child’s best sleep is right around the corner! Go make them happy and restful today!

Check here for details on best infant car seat